Sim League Nirvana

heimer wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 10:03 am that said let’s stop being egregious tankers. there are and have been GMs putting less than their best dc forward and it’s no bueno. just trade them. progressive penalties for tanking violations could help solve this issue. or sign me up for tank police and i’ll absolutely skewer those that are diddling their DCs

Make Heimer a cop!

Tyler wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 10:32 am

jwoo wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 10:28 am Well then!

I am intentionally staying out of the discussion here as the presenter of the rule change - I am neutral and OK with whatever the group wants and decides as far as timeline - but the good news is that we have hit 21 votes in favor of the system itself, so we have a supermajority.

@pacers how do you want to hold the actual runoff vote?

I propose a sack race on neutral turf between Merv and Joe held on consecutive Sundays until a winner is determined. Matt and Sonick will be the official judges. There will be two possible scores, A+ and B-

My sack: 14 picks
Mervs sack: idk maybe 5

I'd say the race is over

ATTENTION: We have now reached the 20 vote threshold.

THE POLL IN THIS THREAD WILL NOW SERVE AS THE RUNOFF. All votes must be in by the END OF THE REGULAR SEASON (Day 120), so as to provide time for offseason planning based on the result of the runoff. Votes submitted or changed after this deadline will NOT count.

Let me know if any questions - thanks all.

ashes wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 2:00 pm

Get outta here dad we're busy having a civil war over nothing

Joe wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 11:29 am

Tyler wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 10:32 am

jwoo wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 10:28 am Well then!

I am intentionally staying out of the discussion here as the presenter of the rule change - I am neutral and OK with whatever the group wants and decides as far as timeline - but the good news is that we have hit 21 votes in favor of the system itself, so we have a supermajority.

@pacers how do you want to hold the actual runoff vote?

I propose a sack race on neutral turf between Merv and Joe held on consecutive Sundays until a winner is determined. Matt and Sonick will be the official judges. There will be two possible scores, A+ and B-

My sack: 14 picks
Mervs sack: idk maybe 5

I'd say the race is over

No sack shaming!

ashes wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 2:00 pm

MOTY candidate @jordo

Tyler wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 2:31 pm

ashes wrote: ↑September 26th, 2024, 2:00 pm

MOTY candidate @jordo

not only that, this is one of the best eps of TV ever

If you all want my actual opinion, it's this:

1. You are arguing over 75% and 80% odds of losing the lotto. At the end of the day, you are losers (1 and 2) that often of the time, so like Jesse said, it's kind of irrelevant

2. I actually agree with Joe/Matt/whomever that fast changes are meh

3. Honestly I don't think it really affects you super tankers THAT much regardless

4. Tanking is pretty ridiculous now and it's really really hard for me to keep up with it, and appointing a tanking mod is ideal, but at the same time opens up to bitching. Like y'all will attack each other, but listen to me, so it's tough.

5. I actually enjoy watching people try to figure out the ways of the tank. But it's usually around this time that people have it down to a science. Flatten it out, make things interesting, have fun. You're still gonna tank no matter what, it isn't the biggest of deals that your odds shift from 75% to 86% of losing.

That's my take tbh

We are currently TIED with the vote closing with the next sim! If you haven’t voted yet - WILL YOU BE THE TIEBREAKER?!