Sim League Showdown: Middle Earth v. Westeros

Post by **Joe** » January 24th, 2025, 2:29 pm

Oberyn Martell must have the most devastating combination of 99 quickness and brutal turnovers at the absolute worst times

Post by **Matt** » January 24th, 2025, 2:29 pm

SoNicks wrote: January 24th, 2025, 2:14 pm
Matt wrote: January 24th, 2025, 2:02 pm
SoNicks wrote: January 24th, 2025, 1:51 pm
you should be proud of the 300rp youll get from working on this as youve clearly maxed out the grading criteria. its an added benefit that you wont be contributing to RP inflation by earning too much on this superb article!!!
This is such a shitty and annoying post
back at you man! maybe ill text you what irony means sometime.

your a member of the 06 and took a leadership role and yet anytime you are faced with criticisms you fucking whine and bitch about it man. you really think im the only person that takes issue with the RPs alloted for really creative pieces? Im just the only one who doesnt give a fuck to call shit out on the boards. your fear of RP inflation has created no incentive for GMs to actually try and put forth great products. Its evident in the complete collapse in content and engagement.

It is ~ironic~ to claim there's no incentive for creative articles in a thread started by an extremely creative article.

Yes, I took a leadership role - the 6 of us put a ton of time and energy to create this league and the hobby that we all enjoy so much, and all we ask in return is the baseline level of respect to not constantly sow seeds of discontent and negativity across the league. I'm not part of the grading committee, I didn't take personal offense to your comment, I'm just sick of reading your passive-aggressive bullshit every time I log on. It's a downer man. You wanna be proud of "not giving a fuck", that's fine, good for you, very brave - but if there's something you want changed about the league, take the time to think through an actual proposal and treat us like adults instead of launching unfunny, unhelpful cheap shots into the abyss. The criteria is published! You want creativity to be weighted heavier, write a rule change proposal!

And to preempt the clap back of course what the 6 of us (and honestly, mostly Jesse) did pales in comparison to the work that Ashes has put into the league and the league doesn't work without an amazing commissioner and 29 GMs who are active and engaged, and we are very thankful that we have both of those things.

January 24th, 2025, 2:29 pm

im honestly kinda pissed Middle Earth got waxed. Sub in Merry and Pippin after drinking that Ent Juice and you got a couple bucket getters!

Post by **SoNicks** » January 24th, 2025, 2:30 pm

Tyler wrote: January 24th, 2025, 2:18 pm
SoNicks wrote: January 24th, 2025, 2:14 pm
Matt wrote: January 24th, 2025, 2:02 pm

This is such a shitty and annoying post
back at you man! maybe ill text you what irony means sometime.

your a member of the 06 and took a leadership role and yet anytime you are faced with criticisms you fucking whine and bitch about it man. you really think im the only person that takes issue with the RPs alloted for really creative pieces? Im just the only one who doesnt give a fuck to call shit out on the boards. your fear of RP inflation has created no incentive for GMs to actually try and put forth great products. Its evident in the complete collapse in content and engagement.
Matt isn’t a content grader and your comment was objectively toxic

It was very toxic and i shouldve displayed restraint and respect. Shown reason and addressed the concern in a peaceable way because unfortunately everything ive said is true.

ill take a step back for a while from the boards for the sake of those who ive offended.

Post by **Jordo** » January 24th, 2025, 2:35 pm

mantypas/CavsCzar wrote: January 24th, 2025, 2:29 pm im honestly kinda pissed Middle Earth got waxed. Sub in Merry and Pippin after drinking that Ent Juice and you got a couple bucket getters!

I was genuinely surprised, I built out Gandalf, Sauron and Witch King to be much better than anyone from Westeros except for maybe Jon Snow player rankings would probably go
1. Sauron
2. Gandalf
3. Jon Snow
4. Witch King

Post by **Jordo** » January 24th, 2025, 2:42 pm

Unfortunate 4 day hip flexor injury for Jaime Lannister, probably from all the incest

Post by **pacers** » January 24th, 2025, 3:26 pm

How is witch king coming off the bench he’s totally OP

Post by **Joe** » January 24th, 2025, 3:38 pm

pacers wrote: January 24th, 2025, 3:26 pm How is witch king coming off the bench he’s totally OP

Witch king is classic Popovich-Manu utility guy. Plays more total minutes than a bunch of the starters but comes off the bench so he can bust up backups like he busted up the gates of minas tirith

Post by **Jordo** » January 24th, 2025, 3:40 pm

He was literally built like son of Manu and Marion

Post by **Clinton** » January 24th, 2025, 4:15 pm

*turns on Fellowship

Login • Register